Mrs. Dalloway |
The Hours |
COMMONalities
In both of the books, characters share similar traits.
Both Clarissas are older, and like to relive their past. Their appearance is somewhat ironic. Seeing as they are older women, one would be lead to believe they had some sort of wisdom, and they do, but both of them choose to ignore it and leave it in their thoughts. Neither of them speaks anything like their thinking aloud, always trying to make the best of any situation. They are older, important looking women with the way they dress and carry themselves. In order to preserve the essence of the original text, Cunningham did not change the character very much. He made Clarissa Vaughan much more aware of and capable of deeper emotions, to add to the character that Virginia Woolf tried so hard to understand in her own mind, but couldn't, because she was so shallow and Virginia Woolf was so insightful. Clarissa Dalloway finds comfort in simple things and the more complex things scare her, but when she hears about Septimus' suicide, she is first devastated but then happy because "he made her feel the fun" (186) and caused her to look deeper into herself and life. This allows her to see the other side of life, whereas Clarissa Vaughan already has this insight given to her by the author. She knows of death, and can infer that Laura Brown "has been worshiped and despised" (221). Cunningham successfully imitates Clarissa and also improves her as a person to make her less of an annoying protagonist for readers.
Septimus is reinvented in Richard Brown, but is reinvented in a less than successful way. Unable, perhaps, to capture Septimus' painfully empathetic mind, Cunningham makes Richard have a much more tangible disease in AIDS. This is also to possibly modernize the character as the nineties had no war to have one be shell shocked from, while instead AIDS, equally misunderstood at that time was a suitable substitute. Changing Septimus is this way was to bring the book into the modern age. Septimus represents Virginia Woolf, also, in some abstract way, as she suffered from depression, and eventually ended up killing herself. One image the two have deeply in common is their hallucinations. Septimus is plagued by hallucinations of his fallen comrade, Evans (66). Richard is visited by shadows and different types of visions (59). As she had originally wanted to make Clarissa end up killing herself, but found it just didn't fit with the character, she subconsciously incorporated herself into the text in the character of Septimus. Cunningham changes him to make him more relatable to modern audiences, but in making him less of an emotional sponge, he made Clarissa more of one to balance the characters out.
Rezia and Laura are similar, but this may a bit of a stretch. Rezia wants so much to be a good wife to Septimus that she keeps herself strong for him. She has moments of weakness where she is just overcome with grief and desire for the past that she has to leave Septimus alone at times, thinking he "wasn't Septimus any longer" (65), but she always comes back to him. She cannot abandon him because she loves him. Laura is much like this, but as readers learn, she does eventually abandon her family and move to Canada. She is devoted to her husband, but only because she feels she must be, because of societal expectations. She finds the world "stunned and stunted, far from everything" (111). Rezia and Laura love their husbands under different circumstances. Rezia loves Septimus and even though she goes through a couple rough patches, she doesn't stop loving him. Laura stops loving her husband. Cunningham changes the Rezia character in this way to show how sometimes things become too much. Because Laura is ridiculed by characters later, and her own son dislikes her for leaving him, he is applauding Rezia for her strength and dislikes Laura for her actions.
------
Several minor characters also share several similar traits.
Peter Walsh and Louis, who visits Clarissa in The Hours, are both dejected lovers, who live in the past and cannot give up on their wish to make their fantasies reality.
Elizabeth and Julia, each of Clarissas' daughters, are rebels and their mothers are not particularly proud of them. This exemplified by their hard relationship.
Mrs. Killman and Mary Krull, the newly turned Christian and the lesbian rebel who is attracted to Julia, but Julia has no idea, are each disliked by the Clarissas and try to take up the daughters' time, but fail when they go back to their mothers.
Lady Bruton of Clarissa Dalloway's world and Oliver St. Ives of Miss Vaughan's world are the eccentric rich people with big, silly ideas. Their purpose is make both Clarissas seem smarter and to contrast the two so readers see that each Clarissa is not so bad. They are somewhat shallow, but they aren't stupid.
And finally, each of the Sallys are the same. They love Clarissa and care deeply for each one.
Both Clarissas are older, and like to relive their past. Their appearance is somewhat ironic. Seeing as they are older women, one would be lead to believe they had some sort of wisdom, and they do, but both of them choose to ignore it and leave it in their thoughts. Neither of them speaks anything like their thinking aloud, always trying to make the best of any situation. They are older, important looking women with the way they dress and carry themselves. In order to preserve the essence of the original text, Cunningham did not change the character very much. He made Clarissa Vaughan much more aware of and capable of deeper emotions, to add to the character that Virginia Woolf tried so hard to understand in her own mind, but couldn't, because she was so shallow and Virginia Woolf was so insightful. Clarissa Dalloway finds comfort in simple things and the more complex things scare her, but when she hears about Septimus' suicide, she is first devastated but then happy because "he made her feel the fun" (186) and caused her to look deeper into herself and life. This allows her to see the other side of life, whereas Clarissa Vaughan already has this insight given to her by the author. She knows of death, and can infer that Laura Brown "has been worshiped and despised" (221). Cunningham successfully imitates Clarissa and also improves her as a person to make her less of an annoying protagonist for readers.
Septimus is reinvented in Richard Brown, but is reinvented in a less than successful way. Unable, perhaps, to capture Septimus' painfully empathetic mind, Cunningham makes Richard have a much more tangible disease in AIDS. This is also to possibly modernize the character as the nineties had no war to have one be shell shocked from, while instead AIDS, equally misunderstood at that time was a suitable substitute. Changing Septimus is this way was to bring the book into the modern age. Septimus represents Virginia Woolf, also, in some abstract way, as she suffered from depression, and eventually ended up killing herself. One image the two have deeply in common is their hallucinations. Septimus is plagued by hallucinations of his fallen comrade, Evans (66). Richard is visited by shadows and different types of visions (59). As she had originally wanted to make Clarissa end up killing herself, but found it just didn't fit with the character, she subconsciously incorporated herself into the text in the character of Septimus. Cunningham changes him to make him more relatable to modern audiences, but in making him less of an emotional sponge, he made Clarissa more of one to balance the characters out.
Rezia and Laura are similar, but this may a bit of a stretch. Rezia wants so much to be a good wife to Septimus that she keeps herself strong for him. She has moments of weakness where she is just overcome with grief and desire for the past that she has to leave Septimus alone at times, thinking he "wasn't Septimus any longer" (65), but she always comes back to him. She cannot abandon him because she loves him. Laura is much like this, but as readers learn, she does eventually abandon her family and move to Canada. She is devoted to her husband, but only because she feels she must be, because of societal expectations. She finds the world "stunned and stunted, far from everything" (111). Rezia and Laura love their husbands under different circumstances. Rezia loves Septimus and even though she goes through a couple rough patches, she doesn't stop loving him. Laura stops loving her husband. Cunningham changes the Rezia character in this way to show how sometimes things become too much. Because Laura is ridiculed by characters later, and her own son dislikes her for leaving him, he is applauding Rezia for her strength and dislikes Laura for her actions.
------
Several minor characters also share several similar traits.
Peter Walsh and Louis, who visits Clarissa in The Hours, are both dejected lovers, who live in the past and cannot give up on their wish to make their fantasies reality.
Elizabeth and Julia, each of Clarissas' daughters, are rebels and their mothers are not particularly proud of them. This exemplified by their hard relationship.
Mrs. Killman and Mary Krull, the newly turned Christian and the lesbian rebel who is attracted to Julia, but Julia has no idea, are each disliked by the Clarissas and try to take up the daughters' time, but fail when they go back to their mothers.
Lady Bruton of Clarissa Dalloway's world and Oliver St. Ives of Miss Vaughan's world are the eccentric rich people with big, silly ideas. Their purpose is make both Clarissas seem smarter and to contrast the two so readers see that each Clarissa is not so bad. They are somewhat shallow, but they aren't stupid.
And finally, each of the Sallys are the same. They love Clarissa and care deeply for each one.